It's Nepal, so sneaking in is easy.
As a foreigner, you're supposed to pay for pretty much everything in the Kathmandu Valley: entering Kathmandu's Durbar Square is 200 rupees, as is Patan's; the Temple atop Swayambo on the west side of town is 100, and Pashuputinath costs 250; 100 rupees to see the Stupa at Boudha; and just to enter the old town of Bhaktapur is 750 rupees. Converted, it's about $3.20 to enter the Durbar Squares, $1.60 for Swayambunath and Buddhinath, $4 for Pashuputinath, and $12 for Bhaktapur. Nepalis get in for free, of course, and the fees are greatly reduced for visitors from the other SAARC countries: India, Bangladesh, Bhutan, Pakistan, Afghanistan, Sri Lanka, the Maldives.
I snuck into Bhaktapur with 3 other expats for Bisket Jatra, the Nepali new year, which involves (in no particular order) a ceremony of moving a lumbering, rickety chariot across town with a very stupid Hindu god tied up inside; a giant tug of war between residents of different sides of the city; and the felling of a giant lingam, which is a huge pole with fronds and ropes attached—it's something like 45 meters tall—stuck in a millstone-shaped stone called a yoni1.
The ceremony of pulling down the lingam first involves teenagers from the town trying to climb up the ropes until someone reaches the very top—not just where the ropes are knotted, but then a clamber past the crossbeam and a bear-hug shimmy to the very top. Everyone cheers, the climber revels in it for a moment, then makes his way back down.
Next everyone grabs the ropes and pulls: the lingam sways unstably like a palm tree in a hurricane, first this way and then that, and the crowd gasps and cheers when it looks like it's going to come down. As the lingam rebounds away from one group—it is wood, after all, and flexes pretty mightily before it will break—those on the ropes closest to the lingam tend to get pulled up into the air, often 20 feet or more. Usually these are tweens or early teens, who seem to have great fun being pulled into the air and then sliding down the ropes again.
At some point, though, the lingam begins to fall, and as many ropes on one side get closer to each other, ropes on the far side also go taut, to keep the lingam from falling too fast or hard. When the lingam finally comes down, there is a great pop of flashbulbs and the sound of cell phone cameras making imitation shutter sounds; then a great melee follows that looks, from inside the crowd, like little else than a massive religious experience: convulsing, stomping, shouting, hands waving, singing, bodies bumping and colliding and bouncing of each other.
If this all sounds recklessly dangerous, well, it is: climbers up the lingam regularly fall, often to their deaths, and in Kathmandu this year the lingam hit a microbus that was passing by. To western eyes, it's pretty incredible, but Nepalis have a sense of humor much more slapstick than ours—while waiting for the lingam part of the celebration, a chubby woman in a bright orange and yellow sari fell almost straight backwards, her feet out from under her and body directly into a folded, sitting position, and hard. Her reaction? To laugh at herself.
But all this is something of a digression, for what I'm interested in—the question I can't yet answer, more or less—is whether sneaking in is, in the end, acceptable2. What follows is less an argument than a cascade of related thoughts, for the interplay of problems is rather complex.
To some degree, not paying for entry is intentionally depriving a Nepali of income. And indeed, the income is considerable: the value of those 750 rupees is much higher to any Nepali than it is to me. At home in San Francisco, I can earn the value of 750 rupees in an hour; even for a Nepali with a better-than-decent job, it's something like two weeks' worth of pay. Past that, it is to some degree replaying the worst aspects of colonialism: a white foreigner comes in, takes what he wants, and leaves without contributing to the community. And indeed, whatever money I spend here will likely be circulated through the Nepali community at least a few times; whatever I save will circulate only at home, where it can do much less.
And yet what I'm taking, of course, is naturally free. Bhaktapur will be there whether I visit or not, whether I pay or not; there is in reality no good or service that some person has provided to me. Bhaktapur is a living place, and it's hard to argue that making a single person pay more is fair—is my “cost” to the town infinitely higher than a Nepali's?
Beyond that, changing prices based on nationality is also problematic. Imagine for a moment that you walked into a grocery store in San Francisco, and everything had 3 prices: one for Brits, one for Mexicans, and one for Americans. Even if tomatoes were priced on per-capita national income—the British paying the highest price, then the Americans, then Mexicans—it would still be a very poor version of a sliding scale economy, and hard to argue that anyone had an obligation to follow it.
It's hard to even reason that you should buy a ticket on a self-interested basis. There is essentially no risk for not paying to enter Durbar Square or the like—the worst that happens is that you wander near a ticket booth, a police officer comes out and asks to see your ticket. If you don't have one, you can either lie and say you're part of a group—the police don't speak English with anything approaching fluency—or you can just pay then. It's not that you're going to go to jail, or even have to pay a fine.
Finally, you could make very much the same argument against bargaining in the developing world as you would make against sneaking in. At heart is a difficult power imbalance: even though I am not wealthy for the first world, I can live like a king in Nepal. As such, I wield a lot more power in most transactions. Basic issues of fairness—it's not fair to cheat me!—make the idea of paying more for consumer goods pale in comparison to the difference in wealth solely attributable to my nationality. The basic idea is: There but for the grace of God go I. We each have no control over the circumstances of our birth, and for the vast majority of us, for our upbringings as well; and yet even outside of choices I've made, I am much wealthier for something I did not do and something neither I nor the Nepali I bargain with had control over: that I was born in the US. That's something that is, in the end, fundamentally unfair to the Nepali. Just like in not paying the entrance fee, I can choose whether to bargain: Buying a kilo of apples at 80 rupees instead of 70 makes little difference to me, but those ten rupees—16 cents—are a fair bit to Nepalis. At what point should you pay more since you can pay more? Should I, then, actually bargain the apple-seller up, till I am paying whatever I would be willing to pay for a kilo of apples in the US?
Again, there but for the grace of God go I.
*
1Lingam and yoni are in fact words for the male and female genitalia, as many of you no doubt remember deep in your brains from exposure to New Age crystal healers, yoga groupies, and the like. The words were certainly in my brain, in any case.
All I can say is that when feminist deconstruction hits Nepal, academics are going to have a field day with Bisket Jatra.
2I am intentionally going to lay aside here the issues of whether you have a moral obligation to follow the law; much less follow the law in a country that doesn't recognize any sort of agency from those who are not its citizens (which is pretty much every country, though possibly not Hong Kong) nor even the citizenship of those born there of parents born there and who are not recognized as citizens by any other nation (i.e., Nepal).
We had an unexpected bout of load-shedding today, so all the battery power for my laptop is going (more or less) to tracking down orphans and networking.
I meant to get up to Boudhanilkantha, but instead biked all the way to the rim of the valley and Shivapuri National Park, where the headwaters of the Bagmati River are--a river holy to Hindus and which winds through Pashuputinath. From up high, the landscape reminds me very much of Dutch landscape paintings, though in many ways Nepal looks little like Holland.
Strangely, up at the entrance the guards--the military--wouldn't let me pay the money to go into the park. I'm not actually sure why that is, but another expat suggested to me that it's because the bodies of 30 Maoists were found in a mass grave there, presumably summarily executed during the uprising. I'm not sure if this is true, but it's the best I have to go on.
I'll tell some stories about these places soon, I promise--the combination of paying for internet and load shedding makes it difficult to schedule time for the computer!
Boudha's the center of the Tibetan Buddhist community in the Kathmandu Valley, and it was hot the day I passed through--high 80s to low 90s between noon and 2.
The little monks are playing cricket with a shingle and a hollow plastic ball knd of like a whiffle ball, but without holes.
A little interlude about my 12 hours in Hong Kong...
I often think of Invisible Cities when I am traveling; especially so here in Hong Kong.
Central Hong Kong is a city of malls—malls that open unto other malls, which lead you to two or three possible doors—all of which lead to still other malls. Malls have large, backlit advertisements for other malls, and when you are spelunking for the subway in wide underground rooms you instead and in fact find a mall with an admission price of one Metro ride. And yet, at times it is difficult for the traveler to know how to arrive at an adjacent mall, the mall you want, as the halls and walkways twist mercilessly to bring you past the most, best shops.
This Hong Kong is a city of not just malls but of status, for the malls lack the means for self-improvement: they lack hardware stores, pharmacies, bookstores of any real depth; they lack cookware, sergers (sp?) and sewing machines, circuit boards and spools of stereo wire. Instead, they repeat the same brand-name luxuries, the Ferragamo shoes and Fendi bags that convey—signal—a knowledge of the vagaries of fashion, knowledge available only to those who can, more of less, afford fashion.
And so, I wonder: is it better—is it more desirable—to live above the Rolls Royce dealer or the Bulgari store in the next mall? Would you rather keep the office of your finance firm above Hugo Boss or Hermes than Clinique? How far does the need to show status—to show luxury, and power—extend? I like to imagine this Hong Kong as a city in which you can give directions by brand name, in which saying that you live above the Admiralty Armani Exchange is normal and precise, like giving a neighborhood or cross-streets.
On the plane to Kathmandu I sit on a roughly upholstered seat next to a Belgian expat named Ann whose partner works—she does not—as an auditor in central Hong Kong. “It's a banker's city,” she says; while the city has a Statue Square very near the central train station, it's only got one statue in it, and that statue is of Sir Thomas Jackson, Chief Manager of the Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation, 1870–1902 (sic). And the suit is de rigeur: in a tropical city, a banker's fashion.
I ask Ann if Hong Kong has any farms. “Maybe a few in the New Territories,” Ann says, “but really you go to the supermarket and all the food comes from New Zealand, Australia, and America. And overland, by truck, from China. Everything is imported.”
After a moment's pause she changes the subject. “Hong Kong is really quite beautiful though.”
I'm not sure these will be quite so "literary" as last time. Or even as proofread. Or even proofread at all.
I'm safe and sound in Kathmandu, staying at a guest house in the neighborhood of Paknajol--right next to (what is essentially) the tourist district of Thamel--and just starting to get myself acclimated to the new surroundings. The last two nights I've fallen asleep right about 9:30 and awoken at 3 am, unable to sleep again till 5 or later, about 5 and a half to six hours' sleep. The water coming off the Himalayas is low right now, so the city, dependent on hydropower and waiting for Indians to finish (by rumor) 20 dams of different sizes, has a "load-shedding" schedule, essentially the same as rolling blackouts. In Zone Two, where I am, the power was out 5 to 9 am on Wednesday morning and 4:30 to 8:30 pm that evening, 5 to 9 pm last night, and will presumeably be out sometime today as well. I seem recall that tomorrow's outage is from 4 to 8 am, but I could be mistaken about that.
Some poorly sourced stats: Tom (the founder of Wrench Nepal) called Nepal the 9th poorest nation in the world; and I read somewhere that the per capita in come is about 9300 Nepali rupees, or about $150. The exchange rate this morning was 62 Rs/USD. Foreign aid is the biggest sector of the economy; and according to the Lonely Planet--which every expat here uses--tourism is the 3rd largest.
Some prices: A handful of grape tomatoes costs 5 rupees; a bottle of water--a necessity, here, because of contamination--is 25. Breakfast this morning was 77 and was a small omelet, a small cup of black tea, 2 slices of toast, and a few baby potatoes. Internet is 30 Rs per hour. My guest house is 400 Rs per night; the cheapest I've heard of was 150 Rs per night, but was negotiated by an Israeli named Nir who has no scruples about extracting every last rupee from the Nepalis at the market, at the hotel, and at shops all around town. I find him distasteful.
Despite concerns and predictions otherwise, Kathmandu was totally quiet and calm during yesterday's elections, and since all traffic was banned from the city because of the holiday it was actually a real pleasure to walk around. You walk in the street here, even when there are sidewalks, and even though it's chaotic it's actually much safer than the US--at least in daytime--there are no streetlights, really, just light from houses and businesses, and not much nightlife--because cars can't build up any speed. That, and that everyone walks.
I'm not sure I can accurately describe Kathmandu, other than that I imagine it's similar to Rome before Mussolini. The buildings are mostly 3 and 4 and 5 stories, made of concrete with walls of poorly mortared brick. The streets are narrow and winding, and most of them don't have names; even when they do have names, there are no streetsigns to help you. Tons of people around, and yesterday at least they were clustering around radios and televisions to get news of the elections. There are lots of bikes altered to carry huge flats of things, or blue plastic water tubs, or to serve as street food stands. And bicycle rickshaws, everywhere.
Picture(s) to come when I find a place with the bandwidth to upload them.
Well, well. After a lovely day of shots and other immunizations I'm ready to formally make my announcement:
On April 7th I'm leaving fair San Francisco for Kathmandu, teaching bike repair to Nepali street kids and orphans with Wrench Nepal. It's kind of like the Bike Kitchen Kathmandu, but also kind of not--and while I've got loads of bike repair and organizing experience, I have pretty much zero experience working with homeless youth. So that will be an interesting challenge. Also on the docket: figuring out what it means to be part of a Western-run community project in the Third World and convincing my charges that Avril Lavigne isn't punk. It's going to be a crazy adventure, and I'll be back (and, I'm sure, completely jet-lagged) at the beginning of September.
I've got a small passel Nepali Rupees in my bag right now, along with an Asian-network cellphone and a slew of business cards. Wrench Nepal is at 123 Bhat Bateni Marga in Kathmandu, but I dunno yet what the situation is on care package delivery. I guess I'll find out when I get there...
Advice, well-wishes, and curses are always welcome, of course!
All in lieu of bike touring to Montreal, yes. This seemed like a much worse idea, and just so much more enticing.